There are many threads here on selecting gear ratio. Search and read. Give us more information and then advice can be more specific. How do you use the vehicle or plan to use it? Which transmission? How has the engine been modified? Are any other modifications planned for the future? Which axles do you have? Are you interested in a traction aid?
EDIT: in your other thread you say it's a '91, so we'll assume it's a 700R-4 and NP241 with electronic speedometer. So yeah, correct the speedometer and that will correct the odometer and then you can calculate mileage correctly. With overdrive I would go to 4.56, which brings the torque up 22%, whereas going 4.10 is only a 10% change. Honestly 4.88 is useable with 35's. Do yourself (and us) a favor and measure how tall the tires really are.