CK5
Register an account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members.

Deciding on an Aftermarket EFi system

GRINCH

1/2 ton status
Joined
Jan 30, 2001
Posts
1,951
Reaction score
7
Location
Helena, MT
I have this posted in my build thread in the 67-72 but I though I would post it here as well. Hoping to get more input.

Here’s my motor specs. It is currently at the machine shop getting prepped. I asked Marty at MTS to help me put a motor package together. I wanted a good idle and some HP/Torque to sand drag with. This is what we came up with.

500 CI Caddy motor bored 30 over
9.3 -1 compression ratio,
Ported polished 76cc heads 2.19/1.84 valves
Cam specs are
.315 lobe .535 valve lift 112 LSA Cam is ground 4* advance so intake centerline is 108 and exhaust is 116
Duration @ .050 is 220 in and 226 ex
1.70 ratio rockers
MTS is estimating that I will have approx 450 HP and 550 TQ.
Peak torque RPM about 2800 (No more winding up the 350)
MSD stand alone dist with external coil.
attachment.php


attachment.php





Fuel system:

I will be running a Edelbrock performer manifold. Dual-plane design

I still haven’t decided on the fuel injection yet.

I put these in order how I have ranked them so far.

1. Retrotek/Professional Products http://www.professional-products.com/EFI_3.php or http://www.retrotekspeed.com/products/powerjection-iii/

Powerjection III (Claims to support up to 650 HP)
I am really leaning towards this setup. I like the plug and play features plus the abilty to also fine tune the parameters if desired. Less wiring and a Wideband O2 Sensor. The only thing I don’t like is the ECM is internal to the unit and replacement parts for the trail.
Cost Around $1600

2. Affordable Fuel Injection http://www.affordable-fuel-injection.com/

Builds a nice kit with all stock parts and ECM. Would be using a 454 TBI unit bored out for more CFM.. Pros: Easily attainable parts Cons: More wiring less management, I would have to burn a new chip for any changes,

Cost is around $1200

3. FAST/Fuel Air Spark http://www.fuelairspark.com/ezefi/default.asp
Almost like the Powerjection but not as programmable. Costs a little bit more as well.

Cost $1900

I know there a lot more options out there and some are cheaper. I don’t want to mess with JY pulls or making my own harness and piecing parts together. Megasquirt and others have there place, But not on my build. I want something plug and go. I haven’t wheeled in over a year and it’s time to get going.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Greg72
Don't forget the Holley Commander 950 system.....around $1600.

There is another system coming from Holley in the next couple of months that will be more like the EZ-EFI and RetroTek systems. It will do the whole "learning" thing so you don't need to program any of the normal maps.

ALSO: Take a look at some of the discussion forums (non-CK5) about Retrotek Speed. I was really stoked about using their kit, but there is quite a bit of negative stuff out there from people who have used the system on hotrods, etc. Maybe a lot of that was "early adopter" issues, but there seemed to be some issues that weren't trivial, so just make sure you know what you're getting into BEFORE you send them (or any vendor) almost $2000 of your hard-earned money. :thinking:

:usaflag:


I stayed away from the Holley because I read a lot of bad stuff on their setups. More was related to their Projection. So maybe they warrant a closer look.
Their Commander kit comes with a narrow-band O2 sensor. Not sure if you can upgrade to a Wideband one. You can get the Holley Commander 900cfm model with 4 85Lb injectors for the 450-600 HP range or 4 75LB injectors for the 375 -525 HP Range. Both flowing in the 900 CFM range The Retrotek has 4 62Lb injectors. :thinking: Time to find some injector charts to see what I will need based on the heads/cam I'm running and the Cubic Inches..

Not much out there yet pertaining to the new Holley Avenger EFI. Don't want to be one of the first one to run it.

Most of the complaints I found on the retrotek were from pre 2007. I did stumble onto some corvette and camaro sites that had some very positive posts and they were all in the 2009 to current range. :dunno:

I still have a few weeks to decide.

In case any one asks why I'm not considering MPFI.
Two reasons.
1. There is no MPFI manifold yet for the Cad 500, I could weld in bungs on mine. No. $$$
2. I read that TBI actually produces more lower end TQ than MPFI, something about the injectors being further away and being able mix with the air better.
 
Just my $.02 worth. One option to considered is Dynamic EFI http://www.dynamicefi.com/ a good option for a couple reasons. Pro's: Cost and Tuning. No need to burn chips, Dynamic EFI is flash programming and fast processor speed. No need to buy tuning software, included in the EBL system. Con's takes time to learn. Wiring is slightly modified from a stock ECM, but a Painless or Affordable Fuel Injection Wiring harness can be modified to work by changing just a few wires. ECM is not stock, so not trail friendly service.

My personal choice for a 500 CI Caddy, (because I do my own wiring, and prom tuning / programming). See my post for TBI Test Bench http://www.coloradok5.com/forums/showthread.php?t=266439 Use a PCM from a 1993 - 1995 GM pickup (red / blue connectors). Use a 454 TBI with 90 lb injectors. Use an adjustable pressure regulator for the fuel. Fuel Injection Connection http://fuelinjectionconnection.com/gpage.html makes a wiring harness for the red / blue connector PCM for about $300. The Pro's ... for me ... low cost, and all service parts are factory, except the PROM. The red / blue connector PCM will control a 4L80E, so tuning / programming for an electronic overdrive transmission is a super bonus that all other aftermarket EFI ECM's options just CAN'T do!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:D

dave w
 
Just my $.02 worth. One option to considered is Dynamic EFI http://www.dynamicefi.com/ a good option for a couple reasons. Pro's: Cost and Tuning. No need to burn chips, Dynamic EFI is flash programming and fast processor speed. No need to buy tuning software, included in the EBL system. Con's takes time to learn. Wiring is slightly modified from a stock ECM, but a Painless or Affordable Fuel Injection Wiring harness can be modified to work by changing just a few wires. ECM is not stock, so not trail friendly service.

My personal choice for a 500 CI Caddy, (because I do my own wiring, and prom tuning / programming). See my post for TBI Test Bench http://www.coloradok5.com/forums/showthread.php?t=266439 Use a PCM from a 1993 - 1995 GM pickup (red / blue connectors). Use a 454 TBI with 90 lb injectors. Use an adjustable pressure regulator for the fuel. Fuel Injection Connection http://fuelinjectionconnection.com/gpage.html makes a wiring harness for the red / blue connector PCM for about $300. The Pro's ... for me ... low cost, and all service parts are factory, except the PROM. The red / blue connector PCM will control a 4L80E, so tuning / programming for an electronic overdrive transmission is a super bonus that all other aftermarket EFI ECM's options just CAN'T do!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:D

dave w

I don't think 454 would flow enough CFM's for me and the injector sizing is too small.
It would be more of an option if I was running a 350 or 454. Although the Cad is only 50CI bigger the HP rating is higher and will require more fuel than I think the 454 Tbi can deliver.

I wish I had time to learn and play around with doing my own.
 
Dave, what do you think of the Powerjection III by Retrotekspeed?

I've read that its chines made, do you know if this is true?

Is the Motorvation cast injector throttle bodie a complete system?

Thanks, Ed

I do not have any personal experience with Powerjection III by Retrotekspeed, or Motorvation. :blush:

I'm a former factory tech, so I use factory parts. It's what I know best. For the most part, I'd use factory parts to make an EFI system. If I were to chose a system, I'd go with the Howell system. The Howell system uses mostly factory parts, and my chip programming / tuning software would work with the Howell system. The only thing I would need to buy would be the 4V throttle body, everything else I have in my garage.

dave w
 
Dave, what do you think of the Powerjection III by Retrotekspeed?

I've read that its chines made, do you know if this is true?

According to their Website and the sticker on the box I received from them, it says,

Engineered, Designed, Manufactured, Tested in the USA in red white and blue!

Easy install Self learn and tunable tables with easy to use software.
P3_kit.jpg

P3_kit.jpg
 
check out this guy for professional advice & tuning on your project:
David C. Johnson
Engineering Program Manager

[FONT=&quot]C[/FONT][FONT=&quot]ommand[/FONT][FONT=&quot]P[/FONT][FONT=&quot]erformance[/FONT][FONT=&quot]E[/FONT][FONT=&quot]ngineering[/FONT][FONT=&quot], [/FONT][FONT=&quot]Inc[/FONT][FONT=&quot].[/FONT]
Littleton, Colorado, USA
[email protected]
http://www.CommandPerformanceEngineering.com
http://www.merchantcircle.com/business/Command.Performance.Engineering.Inc..303-794-6701

[FONT=&quot] He'll even set you up a "dual TBI" which looks just like 2 four barrel carbs !
[/FONT]
 
check out this guy for professional advice & tuning on your project:
David C. Johnson
Engineering Program Manager

[FONT=&quot]C[/FONT][FONT=&quot]ommnd[/FONT][FONT=&quot]P[/FONT][FONT=&quot]erfomance[/FONT][FONT=&quot]E[/FONT][FONT=&quot]nginering[/FONT][FONT=&quot], [/FONT][FONT=&quot]Inc[/FONT][FONT=&quot].[/FONT]
Littleton, Colorado, USA
[email protected]
http://www.ComandPerformanceEngineering.com
http://www.mechantcircle.com/business/Command.Performance.Engineering.Inc..303-794-601

[FONT=&quot]He'll even set you up a "dual TBI" which looks just like 2 four barrel carbs ![/FONT]
Wow! How much do you make from pimping this guy no one else on the internet knows about? :confused:

Dual TBI isn't that complicated and it would take care of the issues I have read in this thread.

Problem with most aftermarket stand alone ECM is a couple things. In a few years they are worthless and unservicable. Second they usually put out the ut-most WOT but don't spend a lot of time with driveability. I like the factory stuff because of the bizillions of dollars that goes into R&D.

454 TBI unit in stock form with adjustable fuel pressure regulater and even a vacuum assist to ease in tuning will handle that motor. But you may give up a few ponies at ut-most RPM. But you will get a much better response, tourque and driveability at bottom end. Bottom end is what I consider drivability. From idle to say 3500. Where you drive all the time.

So you could go one BB TBI or two BB TBI and run a stock ECM and have a harness built. Now you are servicable where ever when ever with auto parts store parts.

So now either get into tuning chips or add a piggy back tuner. This wires into the factory harness and give you all you'll need and more. The ones I have used and like are from Perfect Power, preferably the SMTY8. BTW this unit is very long term reliable and even if you think it failed and left you unservicable on a trail or out of town it comes with a little block off plate. You just unplug the tuner and use the block off and you are back to stock ECM. Which by now the ECM should have one tuned in chip installed by the tuning and changes you have made yourself with the piggy back tuner.
 
I just installed the ez-efi on my blaze. Thing works great and easy to use hardest part was getting the wires routed far enough from the msd 6al box, wires and disy to keep it from setting false codes. Havnt done a fuel econmy test yet but i already know its better.
 
Wow, for that kind of money for an EFI system, the sales force should be wearing a mask and holding a firearm.:mad:

I'll stick with my junkyard junk for an EFI system, and spend my money on a vacation to a warm West Coast Beach.:D

dave w
 
Wow, for that kind of money for an EFI system, the sales force should be wearing a mask and holding a firearm.:mad:

I'll stick with my junkyard junk for an EFI system, and spend my money on a vacation to a warm West Coast Beach.:D

dave w
I agree but some people have more money then time so they buy stuff like this... I enjoy making factory EFI stuff work and it takes time which I have more of then money...
 
Yea i enjoyed making my factory stuff work until i figured out 7 mpg sucks ass. Guess i coulda just changed the cam so the engine would make enough vacuum for the map sensor to work properly. But who wants to miss out on the trips to the pump. Guess i could left the stock motor in there as well that would be awesome as well.
 
Top Bottom