CK5
Register an account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members.

Need a little quick help from a Ford owner....

Fordum

1 ton status
 Premium
Joined
Jul 31, 2008
Posts
11,474
Reaction score
2,319
Location
Fl
Folks, I've got company that just showed up, so I can't post the whole story. After we go to supper tonight, I will follow up with the explanation. I just wanted to get this posted before everybody heads out for the weekend.

If you have an 89ish Ford, 5.8L, 351 engine, do me a favor. This has to be MPFI, bank fire system.
The starter solenoid has one wire to fire it that plugs in.
NOTE: Starter solenoid, NOT ignition coil.

Open the hood, crank the engine. While its idling, unplug the single starter solenoid wire and plug it back in.
And let me know if the idle changes.

If it does, then I'm no closer to figuring out what is going on than I was. If, like I think, it does not, then I am very close to fixing this thing.

I will post the whole sad story later.

Thanks.
 
messed with plenty, no idle change should happen. the exciter wire should have power only when cranking (in park/neutral)
 
OK, everybody is down at the pond looking at my alligator. I told them my leg hurt and I did not feel like walking down, so I could start on this.
My Ford has always started really well. ( After all, it is a Ford........)
Normally, unless its really cold, one quick bump of the starter and its running.

About a month and a half ago, I cranked it up at a friend's house. Started normally.
Drove to the store, came out, and it failed to fire. Good hot battery, good connections. Spun nice and fast, never even sputtered.
Stopped, let the starter spin down, tried again.
After a few seconds, it sputtered once.
Tried it a third time, and it cranked and ran. Sputtered for a few seconds, then ran normally. I thought that was odd, headed to the house.
Got there, tried it, and it took two tries to start.

When it does start, and its cold, the exhaust would gag you. Not rich, smells lean. If it were rich, I would expect to see some black smoke before the cat lights off.
Do not see any.

Fuel pressure reg on this engine is vacuum controlled, and easily replaced. Since it was fairly old, and I was doing some work in that area anyway, I stuck a new one on there.
Normally don't just throw parts at a problem, but I wanted to replace it anyway due to age.

Did not help a bit. I still was thinking that it was a lack of fuel problem. The rail is supposed to hold pressure, but even bumping the key off and on to cycle the pumps did not help.

Its real easy to check the pressure on this truck, it has a test port on the rail. But I do not have a gauge handy. Even so, I doubted it was bleeding down because of the new reg and the cycling of the pumps.

So, if it is starting lean like it seems, it may be that the injectors are not firing while starting at first. Since it has 8, one bad one should let it start normally but with a skip.

I put the truck in the shop Wed. to fix the AC. My mechanic is busy, and I had told him as long as it was cranking, we would let the starting problem slide until we both had extra time.
He had ordered me a new condenser and of course replaced the drier and orifice tube. It took a while to crank in the parking lot to pull it into his shop.

BUT, after pulling a vacuum on the system, and getting ready to fill it, he hit the key and it cranked like old times. He looked at me and started swearing that he had not done anything to the starting part.
I switched it off and it cranked back instantly like it should. When I went to leave though, it was back to its old tricks.

However, now I am getting suspicious of the ignition switch. Especially since it seems to crank well after a couple of tries.
There was a recall about 3 years after I got this truck due to a faulty switch that caused some fires. Mine was replaced, but it has switched thousands of times since.
Maybe the start contact was getting flaky.

So, just before my guests arrived, I went out and popped the hood. Cycled the ignition switch on a couple of times to make sure the rail was pressurized.
Then, I left the switch in the run position. Pulled the little quick connect off the starter solenoid and used a piece of wire to fire the solenoid.
Thus bypassing the start contact in the switch.

It actually seemed to start quicker than it had been, but still not right.
My company drove up to the gate, and I hit the remote control to let them in. As they drove in, I reached to close the hood but then remembered that the starter solenoid was still unhooked.

I reached out, plugged in the wire, and the engine idled up faster instantly. I thought, NO WAY. Since it was cold, the computer was changing the idle as it warmed up.
Had to be a coincidence.
I unplugged the wire, and it idled down some. I stood there, feeling like a fool plugging and unplugging a wire that should be dead, and even if it wasn't should not have an effect on the engine.

But, everytime I did, the engine changed slightly. Sometimes it idled up, sometimes down. Not necessarily the same each time, but it did have an effect every time.
I always have a meter in the truck, so I grabbed it. Measuring between the wire and the contact, i got varying voltage of between 5 and 6 volts.

I wanted to measure from it to ground, but did not have time.

Came in here and posted the question.

Since, I have pulled out my electrical and vacuum troubleshooting factory manual for that truck. And it turns out there is a way for voltage to get on that line.
The start contact not only supplies power to the starter solenoid, but using the same wire, it supplies power to the start terminal of the TFI module mounted on the distributor.
Its an external module that is similar to the module in a GM dizzy.

The computer controls the timing by sending a signal called a SPOUT signal to that module. When it gets it, it fires on the leading edge of that square wave.
But, if the module sees 12 volts coming in on the start terminal, it ignores the SPOUT signal and runs the engine at base timing until that line goes dead.
Thus telling the module that the engine is running, and to let the computer take over the timing.

From what I am reading, that wire should be dead except when cranking. Since is it not, then either the TFI module is breaking down and letting some voltage bleed back on that line, or the ignition switch is crudded up and leaking some voltage to it.
If that is the case, then I am changing the timing when I plug in the coil and bleed off the voltage.

Right now, that is where it stands. I am tied up this weekend, but maybe Sunday I will get a chance to do more investigation.

The gator watchers are back. Watch this space for future developments........
 
Interesting. My truck had all sorts of starting issues from ****ty coolant temp sensors, though not related to your problems. Let us know what you figure out.
 
The newer ford solenoids do have a diode in them,to supposedly keep voltage spikes from affecting the computer...they look different than the "usual" older Ford ones,they have the brass posts sticking up straight instead of out the sides,and the mounting base is slightly different..maybe the diode is flukey?..
 
Same model as mine. Not sure if it has the flyback diode or not. But there is only two ways for a diode to fail.
It can short out, or open.
In this case, if it shorted out, the fuse would blow when I tried to crank it. If it opened, everything would work, but spikes would be generated on the line when the coil was turned off.
That might cause damage to the TFI. But you would not otherwise know anything was wrong.
 
key on engine off, see what voltage is at the wire in question. if you have voltage, unplug the TFI see if it goes away. (would be how I'd start) .... 3rd possibility would be the exciter wire is rubbing another wire.:thinking:
 
Yep, actually my first thought. My story was so long anyway, I left out most of my fuel pump work.
But, its pretty much eliminated as a problem right now.
The only update I have now, is a KOEO test I ran yesterday. Without the engine running, the starter solenoid wire has a steady 7.5 volts on it.

Obviously there is no current to speak of, or the solenoid might be trying to chatter.
With the engine cold and running, the voltage is a fairly constant 7.5, with some variation.
And the difference in idle is obvious. After it warms up, the idle does not vary all that much every time I pull the wire.
Plus the voltage is all over the place. I have not put a scope on it, but I am pretty sure I am looking at an artifact of the SPOUT signal that the computer is sending to the TFI.
Its looking more and more like a breaking down TFI module.
That module has one characteristic that it shares with the distributor modules in Blazers.
That is. that off the truck testing is pretty much a waste of time.

I can replace it for about $20 or so. I'm tied up today and tomorrow, but with any luck, I will slap one on Wed.
I hate the long cranking times, and the fact that I am driving a truck with a known problem.
But, as they say: "Needs must when the Devil drives", and as long as the truck is running, it has to roll right now.
Just too much going on right now.
 
Yep, actually my first thought. My story was so long anyway, I left out most of my fuel pump work.
But, its pretty much eliminated as a problem right now.
The only update I have now, is a KOEO test I ran yesterday. Without the engine running, the starter solenoid wire has a steady 7.5 volts on it.

Obviously there is no current to speak of, or the solenoid might be trying to chatter.
With the engine cold and running, the voltage is a fairly constant 7.5, with some variation.
And the difference in idle is obvious. After it warms up, the idle does not vary all that much every time I pull the wire.
Plus the voltage is all over the place. I have not put a scope on it, but I am pretty sure I am looking at an artifact of the SPOUT signal that the computer is sending to the TFI.
Its looking more and more like a breaking down TFI module.
That module has one characteristic that it shares with the distributor modules in Blazers.
That is. that off the truck testing is pretty much a waste of time.

I can replace it for about $20 or so. I'm tied up today and tomorrow, but with any luck, I will slap one on Wed.
I hate the long cranking times, and the fact that I am driving a truck with a known problem.
But, as they say: "Needs must when the Devil drives", and as long as the truck is running, it has to roll right now.
Just too much going on right now.

The very first sign of a fuel pump failure.
 
Yep, that is what I thought at first. The tank pump was fairly new, it had been replaced by mistake because of a bad connector plug.
Ford uses a plugin connector for the pump and sending unit on top of the pump module.
The tank pump had been acting flaky, and I swapped it out. When it did not last, I looked things over more carefully, and discovered some hidden cracks in the plastic plug.
Replacing the plug fixed that. But problems persisted. A check of the fuel pressure showed a problem with the high pressure pump and it was changed.

All this was done back in Dec. I used a Carter high pressure pump, and hated it from the first time I turned it on.
Its mounted on the frame right under the driver's seat, and had a loud annoying whine.
Not a problem when driving, but if I pulled up to a drive through to get something to eat, I had to turn off the truck.
That whine went right into the mic on the ordering box, and they could not understand my order.
Plus all my friends told me they knew when it was my truck coming because they could hear the whine.

So, when the long cranking times suddenly started, I was delighted. Figured it was the high pressure pump again, and I could get rid of it.
But, despite multiple checking, the pressure on the fuel rail stayed at spec. It would gradually leak down after an hour or so, but jump right up to spec as soon as you turned on the key.
And held there all while the engine was running.

So that is why I figured that it was not a fuel pump issue.

Final update, I changed the LSI module. The voltage at the starter solenoid coil with the key on, engine off, went from 7.5 volts to full battery voltage.......
Of course, there is no current to speak of, or the starter would be cranking. It drops to zero when you hook up the coil.

But, the problem seems to be fixed. It cranks first thing now. I did change the high pressure pump anyway, using the long cranking time as an excuse.
Blessed silence now.....
Pretty sure it was the module.
 
Top Bottom