Both sides were being silly so I decided to write out what I thought, but I need to wait 23 more hours after registering a minute ago to post. So, here you are No situation is perfect. Not everyone is going to live. I don't mind people who are against concealed carry or even firearms in general, just please don't come after mine. I think the problems are the result of a lack of personal responsibility and morality, along with a large amount of people being uninformed and reactionary. I was recently in a "situation" involving an attack. It was easily resolved, but it was interesting to see who cried and ran around in terror, and who was calm and handled the situation. The people who stayed calm were myself and a 50 something man who was, for lack of a better term, and old world "cowboy" Everyone just needs to get along The defense of life is important. You can have people responsible for a large amount of other peoples' safety, or everyone can be taught to be responsible for themselves. This will never be true, but if it happens enough, there will be enough responsible people everywhere to help out society. It's just not carrying pistols. It's stopping to help someone on the side of the road. My gun allows me to do this with no fear. No man should be so afraid as to not do what's right, be that with fists, hands, knives, or guns. Remember that (I hate to use this example) that a vastly outnumbered group of people created a massacre and atrocity because they had at their disposal.... box cutters There needs to be a commitment to do what's right, to the point of embarrassment, to the point of violence, to the point of wounding, to the point of death. We will never have a completely perfect solution, so it's useless to argue. It's a question of personal responsibility. The police can help you a lot of time in violent situations, but sometimes they can't. At that point your commitment to pacifism comes into its true test. Will you die for what you believe in? An armed man has the same decision. In a split second he has to consider being sued, hurt, killed, killing someone, accidentally killing someone he didn't intend to, wounding bystanders, the safety of not becoming involved, and his responsibility for the life and death of himself or someone else. Make your decision, stick with it, and try to live with it if you can. Kill or be killed, kill or have someone relatively innocent dead for your inaction. I won't grudge you your fear, I will be sad. I hope my pistols never leave their holsters. I hope I never have to hurt anyone. I hope discussion becomes to main weapon of conflict. I also hope I can keep my pistols, and I hope that if used, it will be in the most logical and just way. The man did what he should have, I believe, and a woman was possibly saved. He made his decision. A man died as a result of an armed citizen brought on by his own action. It's not a question of pure wrong or right, but of what is the better situation. The woman being alive is the better, in my opinion. It may have been resolved in another way where everyone was alive, but that may have been balanced by the risk of even more people dying that the attacker. Stay safe, and if you choose to, stay armed. Respect people and be just and intelligent. No justice should ever be done in glory, only in sadness, that someone had to die for the best outcome.