I hear you. I've had American, German, and Japanese cars as my daily drivers. And Japanese, British, and American motorcycles. Each one has its benefits and drawbacks, most of it comes down to a feeling. I feel emotional pull towards certain cars and categories/types/classes of cars and a strong repulsion towards others. Neither are right or wrong, just feelings.I totally agree that most older Japanese cars are probably more comfortable, reliable, maybe even more frugal, but for some reason every time I get one I can not wait to pass it on and go back to American made cars.
Maybe it's the same reason I try to keep my local mom and pop stores alive versus saving some money and feeding the beast.
My wife and my daughter are driving the Japanese cars now, the only non American car I have is the Mercedes diesel for obvious reasons
I couldn't stand driving my mother-in-law's Honda CRV, but I enjoy driving my wife's Mazda CX-5. I dislike driving my mom's Buick Enclave, but I enjoyed driving my Ford Crown Vic Police Interceptor.
Cars are weird.

