No offense, but i think your price is out in left field. Yes, they are sorta rare in teh craigslist market, but i SOLD a set that was in BRAND new condition for $200 or 180. They were flawless, looked like they came out of the box. Had like 25 miles on them.
That person got a great deal from me, but i bought them for less. Depending on demand, i think $250-300 with caps and lugs is a lot more fair.
Don't mean to be a jerk, just thought the input from someone who constantly buys/sells on craigslist might be helpful.
If you'd rather i delete this post, let me know.