I have the cap in one truck and the urathane dash in the other. The cap isn't going to win you any points at car show, it isn't a pefect fit, there are a few places where you can see the old dash. It holds up tp sun pretty well, but does scratch easily.
The urathane looks better, is a solid color and is suppose to hold up well to sun (mines only been on a few month). The are not made that well. The metal clips for screws which are placed in the mold were in the wrong spots, I had to install a few clips on my own and drill the urathane, the dash was a little short - there is a good size gap to the guage cluster on the left.
I didn't like either that much, but it's cheaper than the $500 Just Dashes charges to remake your existing dash.
You get what you pay for, but for $200, I was hoping the urathane would be better. It does look much better than the cap though.
Eric M.