ok... let's see if I can work thru this and not have it get all disconbobulated....
first.. you'd never be adding gel, like over paint, that's very bad... gelcoat is polyester based, it needs to be on top of other poly products, such as fiberglass..
ok, let's go over the pro's and con's of each.. which will lead to my thoughts on the subject....
gel - exceptionally durable to scrapes, chipping, scratches, etc... very, not user-friendly and labor intensive... and finally, poor UV protection.. ever wonder why every boat more than a few yrs old usually looks like chalk?
paint- poor durability to scrapes, chips, scratches, etc.... MUCH more user-friendly, and FAR less labor intensive... excellent UV protection... oxidize at a MUCH slower rate than gel, thus they stay shinier MUCH longer...
now... when Dave e-mailed me, i decided to go out back to take a peak and verify my thoughts... first all production fiberglass parts will ALWAYS have gelcoat on them... this includes K5 tops... what is initially on the fiberglass is gel.. now, i'm pretty certain my old 77 was straight white gelcoat.. which would explain the white streaky chalk stuff... smooth over the glass, with a texture sprayed on...
what i noticed last night on my 87 is much different.. it is white gelcoat on the glass (gel can also be ANY color btw).. but it appears that it was overcoated with paint to get the color, and texture... probably an enamel considering the timeframe... the texture on this 87 is much finer than my 77 was... it appears to be more of an added nonskid, like I would do with the nonskid of a boat.. basicaly add fine particles to the mix..
whereas the 77 was a "sprayed" non-skid.. where the gun, usually a hopper style, controls the texture..
with all that gibberish said.. and what i would have told you in the first place is, i wouldn't recommend gel... mainly due to oxidation factor...
lets leave non-skid out of the mix for now.. being you have glass showing, obviously the whole top will need to be sanded down pretty extensively and for ease, we'll say you go smooth...
for paint..... rip down with sander, nip out frays and resaturate those areas with resin.. sand/prep those areas.. fill prime whole top... sand with 320, paint...
gel - rip down with sander, nip out frays and resaturate those areas with resin.. sand/prep those areas.. gel - for smooth gel, YOU HAVE TO WETSAND AND BUFF EVERY SQUARE INCH.... buff...
the caps are the big point... whereas paint lays out shiney, glossy, done, other than a scuff and buff for dust, the gel requires extensive wetsanding and buffing..
now there are a couple of exceptions.... i use a product that really adds shine to the gel and eliminates much of that work, but it is kinda special process/product...
if we need to get into doing textures, let me know.. thats an entire subject unto itself..
in short Dave, just prep it like your gonna paint it... you need to resaturate the dry areas a bit with polyester resin (fiberglass), then sand the entire thing with like 150 to 180... prime the whole top.. paint....
or...
you could roll herc on it.....
or..
you could throw a bunch of sand in some rusto and roll it on there....
