All drip deflectors created equal?

[KiwiK5]

I've read a lot about deflectors in other threads, but I haven't seen any comparison of new parts from various suppliers.

LMC sells theirs for $23 a pair.

Early Classic Enterprises has a set for $39.

Is Early Classic gouging? Is LMC selling crap?

The original deflectors are stiff rubber stuff molded on metal plates. I can imagine that fabricating new ones without the metal might be cheaper, but also might make them less effective.

I've had a chance to look at the Early Classic deflectors. They are molded on metal and feel substantial, but $40 sounds steep, especially when I haven't had a chance to really check out the competition.

 

[Greg72]

I wish I knew......


That IS one of the frustrating things about these older trucks. A lot of the parts are all repros from China/Taiwan, but it's hard to know if a "real" replacement part exists (NOS) or at least a higher quality reproduction.

The difference in price might seem to indicate that the parts are different (and one might be better) but it's equally likely that they are the same and one company is just "soaking" you more....

If it was an important part, I might be tempted to buy one of each....compare them with my own eyes and send back the one I didn't want.

 

[mr_blasto]

That is totally remarkable! I was just looking for some of these the other day and was thinking the exact same thing as far as Early Classics vs LMC. Unfortunately I never made a decision and ordered some. Let me know which you go with and how it turns out cause I am definitely in the market.

 

[BobK]

I ordered mine from GMC Pauls.They have the metal inside and all the holes lined up perfectly.Nice soft pliable rubber as well.

 

[OLD DAWG]

My LMC's tore after about 18mo.

 

[70jimmy]

I am just going to run without them since I don't like the look of the deflectors running beyond where the door is cut above the window.