I've sold rebuilt carbs in the past, that sat on warehouse shelves long enough to let the float corrode,or the accelerator pump dry up--they do have a shelf life..also some carbs with foam floats might not have had ones rated for ethanol put in them..
Maybe I'm just unlucky,but my experience with all Holley's excepting a few Holley Economaster carbs that performed great, is they are always in need of fiddling and adjusting endlessly,when they aren't flooding,stumbling on acceleration,etc...
It took me a month to get one "dialed in" with the correct accelerator pump and adjustments to cure an off idle "bog",and I had to try several different secondary opening diaphram springs before I got it to run good enough to satisfy me..then winter set in,and it started aggravating me again..
I spent hours and $$$ on parts and still wasn't that impressed..to me the Holley's seemed too sensitive to weather conditions,humidity and temparature..it'd run great one day,then sucky the next ,if it rained,or cooled off..in winter they liked to backfire and blow power valves if I opened the choke too soon..(I had a hand choke on them )..
No doubt they do make an engine run much better once dialed in right--but you may never find that sweet spot..
I prefer a stock carb like a Q-jet--rebuild it once,throw it on,adjust the mixture and choke--and drive it thousands of miles,trouble free..and they behave much better off road than a Holley by far..