The piston I am going to use is a seal pro # SLPWH345ACP30 with a coated skirt and the new digital diamond profile. The Summit web site shows the piston head volume to be a +5.00 for the flat top with 4 valve reliefs. I called the Seal Pro tech line and the tech told me that the volume is a - 6.90 cc, I questioned him about the - and he said that any dish piston or a piston with valve reliefs, you should use a - instead of the +. This is differant from everything I have read or been told. It should be a + for dish and - for a dome but the Seal Pro tech said that everything I have been told is wrong??????? This is how all my research has been when it comes to picking the right piston and also on how much compression you can have and still use 87 octane gas. I have been told everything from 10:1, to can't go over 8.7:1 to run 87 gas. I am so confused....
The + vs - thing depends completely on the calculator you are using. It is not a rule or a fact, it's just whatever point of view you look at it from when you write the calculator. I have a dynamic compression ratio calculator in the COG forum available for download, and I use a negative number for a dished piston. That makes more sense to me, because the dished piston takes up less volume, results in less compression, the dish sits lower in the combustion chamber, etc.
However, a dished piston will give you a larger swept volume, so some people look at it that way.
Just make sure you know what calculator and what piston manufacturer you are using(they write the specs for their pistons), and use a positive or negative accordingly. Many flat top pistons still have a slight dish effect because of the valve reliefs.
And you are getting different numbers from different people because it's not a number set in stone. There are a lot of variables for maximum compression, such as camshaft profile, operating temperature, cylinder head material, combustion chamber shape, connecting rod length, spark plug location, RPM, load, etc. So you can't just say, "9..0015:1 is the limit for 87 octane".
These guys are steering you on the right track, 9:1 is probably fine. The dynamic compression ratio is a better indicator of maximum compression for your engine. But setting a limit for maximum dyn compression for 87 octane isn't really an exact figure either.