Gasket not 100% showing imprint + dark color = possible leak point .
Get a thick gasket / check carb pad with machinist stright edge for flat .
Then if good its in the carb .
That’s almost exactly what I was gonna say. That gasket is suspect. My advice, get a new thick gasket, be nice to it.
I’ll be dead honest, the only time I’ve had a good running Holley carb, was when I was a teenager(many, many moons ago)
I couldn’t get mine to run correctly either. I remember assuring both primary and secondary butterfly blades were closed completely, by tweaking the actuator rods on both sides of the throttle body.
Then replaced the secondary jets one size up from recommended. Then, disconnecting the upper secondary butterfly blade actuator rods, and safety wiring the upper blades wide open. Then plugging all vacuum parts accept the ported one to the distributor.
And, the choke linkage totally disconnected.
That way, when you nailed the throttle the secondary’s were in full operation, along with the primary’s already in use. When the transmission kicked down, the engine would rocket straight to the moon. But, at idle, with the primary’s butterfly blades closed, it would idle at 700 rpm all day.
Was it correct? No. Did it work? Yes.
Win! For a 16 year old kid relying on what I saw other people doing to get their junk to run, I was totally happy with it.
As a second idea. I had a real problem with worn throttle rod vacuum leaks, I’m not sure what their called the rods the run horizontally through the venturies, the butterfly blades attach to them. Where they pass through the side of the carburetor itself, after a while Holley’s wear out there. They make a teflon repair kit for it. Essentially, it’s just a small piece of teflon that fits around the shaft into the outside of the carburetor to seal up the worn gap. It’s a PITA to do, because you have to take all the linkages off the carb to install it correctly.
And like Wes said, use a machinist straight edge and a file to assure the bottom surface of the carburetor base is perfect flat.