hmatiak
1/2 ton status
even with a higher quality shaft,the ring gear cant take much more pressure than a 35 inch tire.then you upgrade that and you are breaking hubs.no real upgrade for that other than replace the drive gear every time you strip it.and even with better shafts,if you have a pretty high torque on it and it snaps the joint,you still have it slappin around in the knuckle and may break that also along with many people saying that it sometimes breaks the ears off the shaft.so there goes your 500 dollars worth of heavy duty shafts.as i said,a 44 or 10b can be made stronger.but it doesnt make it bulletproof or strong enough to handle more than a 35 inch tire consistantly without breakage.the biggerst i would go would be 37 and that is pushing it,even on a built axle.on road wheel bearings will go out a lot faster and balljoints get weak much over a 35 inch tire.in the end,you end up with a 1200 dollar axle still weeker than a stock 60.which is whats needed for tires over 35 to 37 inches.its a fact not a opinion.he wanted to know the difference between the 2 and strength of the 2 and thats all that was stated.if you have had good experiences with running bigger tires,then good.its not the norm for a 1/2 ton axle to hold up to that abuse.and most do not.
The only thing im disagreeing with is the fact that either the 10B or D44 is only good for a 35. Now if your locked and on stock shafts, then yea, a 35 would be it if you wheel often and have a heavier foot. Most folks with 1/2 ton fronts, ive seen, wheel them open.
But with some well spent money, that's still allot cheaper than a D60, you can have either hold up to a decent size tire. They will handle more abuse than they are given credit for. People break a stock 10B or D44 and go spend 800 on a 60 then spend more bucks going through it. Thats not including whatever you decide to do to match the rear to the front. 400 compared to 1200-1500 is a good investment to me.

you got me there.thx for the calrifying numbers.haha.i know my 72 shaft was knecked down compared to the 78 shaft i replaced it with.didnt look like it had been replaced with a aftermarket.but you never know.i thought that in 73 they stopped making the knecked down shafts because of breakage.
