I always had good luck with Carter AFB's,and I have had a few Edelbrocks,that are about as good,but the 625 CFM Carter's had better power and throttle response that the Edelbrocks for some reason--weird because they are almost identical clones,and not much different in CFM..........................................................................................................................my only gripes with the Edelbrock was the fact one on my plow truck would starve,flood or die when I climbed up a snowbank with a full blade!....the Q-jet would run until it tipped over without a sputter,but it had a aggravating flat spot just past idle I couldn't get rid of..........................so I swapped an aluminum intake on it and got a used 1406 Edelbrock cheap at a swap meet and parked the Q-jet on a shelf....my gas mileage went down a bit ,the square bore carbs are not as thrifty with fuel as those small Q-jet primaries are,but I liked how it boooted with the secondaries kicked in...........................................................................................................I never had that much love for Holley carbs,but I did have a 450 CFM one on a 1974 454 ,it was one that never came with any choke,not even a shaft or butterfly!--it sucked starting it cold ,and driving till it warmed up in cold weather was "fun",but man,that thing made that engine roar!...and I could get 15 mpg if I drove it like grandma,probably no choke saved a lot of gas??....another spread bore Holley 750 I had that was a Q-jet replacement "bolt on" deal worked very well,it had vacuum secondaries,all I had to do was change the spring in the secondary diaphram unit,to get it to boot in right................................................................................................................but I've also had a dozen other Holleys that never ran worth a crap,backfired,set the air cleaner on fire,no matter how you adjusted the floats,etc...the power valves were probably junk,I just went with Q-jets or Edelbrocks and Carters ,they seemed to run good with minimum fuss and you weren't always trying to "tweak" them...Holleys seem to need adjusting every day when the weather changes sometimes..I do think when the Holley decided to run well,they produced the most power..I liked the "Economaster" Holleys,I had a few of those that were 450 CFM's and bolted up to a Q-jet manifold (model 4360).......I have a 2 bbl one on my 307 in my van too....