To answer your question: no, fender flares aren't very popular around here except where the law mandates them, of course there are exceptions. Depending on what they're made out of, often hard plastic, they can get broken relatively commonly off road. I originally got mine several years ago to cover up my first off road dent (fell into a rut and dented the drivers front fender) and to open up the fenders to install bigger tires. Went from 35's to 37's and was happy for a while. Then when I went to 40's there was still too much fender there, even with the cut-out, so I had to remove a decent amount of the flare. And the dent isn't such a big deal anymore. Truthfully I would like to get rid of them now, but I really can't because they would leave behind a bunch of tiny holes. That said, I have had good experience with bushwacker customer service and currently have a brand new flare that they sent me for free sitting in the barn loft (due to a small crack protruding from one of the screw holes...waiting for bigger carnage to actually replace it). Thus far, any breakage I have experienced has been likely due to tire contact (concentrated around bottom-rear of front flares), and I simply cut more flare off. I do think they look good, some don't, but for offroad they aren't the most practical solution in my opinion. A quality trim job is probably a better option. Not to mention the bushwackers aren't cheap. I have been able to avoid several breaks because my tires seemed to stick out just a touch more than the flare, but then that kind of defeats the purpose (other than looks). Nonetheless, I'll try to get some close ups of my trim job in the next day or so. So in short, here's my opinion: If it sees more pavement than dirt and you like the look, go for it. If its more trail dedicated, consider just cleaning up the trim job.