learning to weld can be tuff, you need to take all variables out of it, so you can really focus on learning, part of being able to weld is to trouble shoot problems, so being comfortable, having the right stuff, having the machine set right will allow you to learn. one thing being wrong will throw you off, and while you think it's because you don't know how to weld it can be some other variable, thats why I always recommend taking a class, or if you know someone who welds they can set you up and check out what you got going on. post up some pics or video and I can or some of these other guys on here can get you going in the right direction. the mig will be easier to learn because you get to see the bead (no flux). but flux isn't too bad, just make sure you are running on some 1/4" thick metal thinner metal can be harder with flux core. another tip I can give you is LWS always marks their stuff way up and they will negotiate prices so never pay asking price, you gotta hear their quote and then tell them you want the good guy price.... and beat them down as low as you can.... you get it.
switch to shade 10, 10 is sufficient for what you're doing 11-12 is dark