I think the problem is your shackle. It is so long it is rocking the axle down just put some shims under the springs and bring it back up to where it needs to be or move the rear mount up to the top hole on your shackle. I have 4" springs and I run the 4.250" shackle from ORD. and my pinion is almost perfect and my caster? is at 8*
When I looked at the pictures, that is the first thing I thought too.
