You might contact Redline direct and ask them about which one would be right for your area (NY). I live in AZ and it helps it stay thinner, but it is still pretty thick. I did spend last winter in Colorado and had no problems with it that I am aware of. I changed my rear oil awhile back and everything looked great.
The oil was contaminated, but I think that wasn't the gear oils fault. I was driving around all winter without my vent tube conected so I think I got some water in there from driving around in 3 ft of snow during the blizzard there. /forums/images/graemlins/crazy.gif
They do make thinner varieties of the shockproof oils so you can go that route too. I run the heavy stuff because of the AZ factor, but I didn't and wouldn't have a problem with running the heavy in a cold winter again.
When you do your oil change make sure to get as much of the old oil out as possible and then (if its cold) make sure you rotate your axle while on jackstand so the oil has time to get to your wheel bearings while there is no load. Once you get oil out there you will always have oil out there. That is the no joke.
I have a specific funnel for my gear oil, and that funnel still has gear oil on it, and it hasn't pooled at the bottom. I swapped my gear oil in June. That should tell you how well it sticks.
Harley