I have experience with both types. My truck is a 78 k2500 with a 9' cabover. First I used Airlift bags with an in cab compressor. Having on the fly adjustability was great and the ride was pretty good. It did have an occasional leak which always turned out to be the line end at the bag...easily fixed. The bags held up fine and were never a problem, but the thing that concerned me was how tweaked and distorted they got when driving on rutted and off camber dirt terrain. So much so, that I switched to Helwig progressive helper springs, for fear of the air bags blowing. In my case my regular leaf springs are soft, and if a bag blew on the road, it would be a bad thing! In comparison, the Helwigs ride good with the camper on, but stiff as hell unloaded, and obviously it takes more time to adjust them....A socket wrench does the trick. But at least they are reliable as a brick. So, if the forest roads aren't too rutted up, and your truck isn't off roaded the bags are a good choice. If you want complete reliability, and if your camper is on your truck most of the time, the helper springs may be the way to go.