CK5
Register an account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members.

How many transmissions have you broke?

How many?

  • 0

    Votes: 7 11.3%
  • 1-2

    Votes: 13 21.0%
  • 3-4

    Votes: 19 30.6%
  • 5-8

    Votes: 16 25.8%
  • 9+

    Votes: 2 3.2%
  • parts killer

    Votes: 5 8.1%

  • Total voters
    62
I have an early model 4L80E with over 200,000 miles on it starting to develop a whining sound coming from the pump. It may be the pump bushing, or the overdrive (overrun) planetary wearing out. I have a couple thousand dollars set aside to rebuild this transmission myself. I am going to fix all the known problems these 4L80E transmissions have such as internal dual feed, rollorize output shaft, case saver, and several other things.
 
I have never ruined a transmission, and I have owned 50 or more vehicles going back to 1980. The closest I have come is buying a car with a ruined transmission, replacing it and never having another issue with it. I'm almost ashamed of myself...
just means you are in tune with your machines!


I have a friend that breaks EVERYTHING. I accuse him of having heavy feet, weak legs, and bad eyes... every time he climbs in a toy - something gonna happen.

but, i tell him not to be ashamed of that -because everyone is concentrating on the limp wrists
 
I never bought new vehicles so driving used cars is like riding a ticking bomb, and I have lost too many to count that way.
But I did break 3 auto transmissions.
The first was a 2wd th350 in my van, I revved the engine while I had it in neutral waiting for the light, then dumped it into drive and matched the go pedal, and I didn't go...
The slip yoke shattered and took out my tail cone on the transmission.

Second was a th350 in my 4wd k5, I didn't have a brace on the np203 tcase and broke my case on the transmission, very common.

Third was my th400 in my jeep wagoneer, I built this jeep on a budget and I didn't know much about driveshaft angles and my front had some weird angles, so one day after hours of snow wheeling, the cv broke and the driveshaft whipped and wedged between the transmission case and the crossmember, and we all know who won that battle.
The red was so awful on the white snow.
We spent more time picking up all the contaminated snow in sealed buckets.
 
I never bought new vehicles so driving used cars is like riding a ticking bomb, and I have lost too many to count that way.
But I did break 3 auto transmissions.
The first was a 2wd th350 in my van, I revved the engine while I had it in neutral waiting for the light, then dumped it into drive and matched the go pedal, and I didn't go...
The slip yoke shattered and took out my tail cone on the transmission.

Second was a th350 in my 4wd k5, I didn't have a brace on the np203 tcase and broke my case on the transmission, very common.

Third was my th400 in my jeep wagoneer, I built this jeep on a budget and I didn't know much about driveshaft angles and my front had some weird angles, so one day after hours of snow wheeling, the cv broke and the driveshaft whipped and wedged between the transmission case and the crossmember, and we all know who won that battle.
The red was so awful on the white snow.
We spent more time picking up all the contaminated snow in sealed buckets.

I like that that story ends in a clean up effort! I've never had a massive mess like that- but I've been in predicaments where if it were to happen, it could have gone both ways... never plan on painting mother earth all kinds of whore colors- sometimes it happens?
 
Had a friend bring in his '82 C10 Short bed, TH350, complaining of a massive transmission fluid leak. I climbed under it and looked. Nothing major. Tightened the cooler lines. Took it for a drive. Transmission worked perfect. Burt the tires off in first, shifted great. Went back to the shop, and backed it into a parking space. When I put it into reverse, and gave it some throttle, it blew fluid 20ft sideways out from under the truck, and all over my K5. Turns out, the case had a spiral fracture all the way thru the transmission. It would only open up in reverse. Didn't leak a drop, otherwise.
 
Man, I have been wrenching or racing or beating on stuff for 29 years, before I could drive on the road, the stories I have...

One time when I was about 18 I was driving the regal on an old country road, was a really long straight away with no one around, so I decided to romp on it, ran it up to over 90 MPH, and then bumped neutral with the column shifter to coast for a while, only I went one too far and bumped reverse. :doah:

Slammed me forward against the seat belt, as I was trying to get it back into neutral with the column shifter, I finally get it back and look in the rearview mirror, I see two black straight lines on the road with streaks of tire smoke coming off of them. I coast down to a stop, test forward, test reverse, start driving it. Nothing, not a damn thing was damaged. The TH400 from Hipster and the 12 bolt didn't care.

So then about 6 or 7 years later I put nitrous on that car too, sprayed around 175 HP on pump gas, cast hyper pistons, stock cast 400 crank, stock SBC rods. I had built that engine when I was 18. Sprayed it maybe 40 times over a 10 year period, plus all the NA passes which was more often. I would only spray it the last pass or two since I would get kicked out for no cage running mid 10s. Drove it home everytime! Same 12 bolt for nearly 20 years.

I did swap the trans to a 4L80E I built in my garage in about 2010. I sprayed that one too.

Then I figured, that wouldn't kill it, might as well put a 632 BBC in front of it, and spray that! That trans is still going to this day, although I can't imagine it has too many runs left at this point, its 12 years old or so with many 632 passes, and the car weighs 3700 lbs with me in it and it runs 9s on motor and just into the 8s on spray. I'm waiting for the clutches to give up the ghost. I did put a 4340 input and intermediate shaft in that trans, among other upgrades when I built it, along with the transbrake valve body.

Around 2008 or so I rebuilt a TH400 for my truck with the SBC. Did a few minor upgrades, had less than $600 in parts. 34 element sprag, rollerized output, dual feed the directs, home made shift kit, etc. Beat on it for a couple years, everything was great.

Then I put the 489 I built in. Drove it a few times, thought everything was great. But on the way home from work one day I realized it was only shifting once...? After further drive testing I realized it had no second gear, it was either 1st, or 3rd(2nd would act like 1st). Tore it apart, found the sprag rolled. Had to take it to work to measure with a micrometer, the direct drum I had purchased was .002" out of round. I replaced it with a direct drum that was in spec, and a new sprag, and I have been beating the snot out of that trans for 13 years now, sand dunes, mild towing, dirt drags, off-roading, etc. It's about to get sold when I put in another 4L80E I will build. So I guess that counts as 1 trans so far, does it even count if you can still drive it home just fine? I had to replace the direct drum, but the trans is still alive.

I do remember once when I was about 14 my father and I were offroading in the old 77 GMC 3/4 ton 4x4 he had. Mild 355 with a cam, intake, and headers. We were snow wheeling in the winter, I got out to spot because he was getting buried, so he floored it in 4WD, put in reverse, and floored it again, and it stopped moving and puked tranny fluid. Turns out the TH350 broke at the case right in front of the Tcase adaptor. I don't really count that because I only witnessed it, wasn't me that broke it. Several years later we were wheeling, he was in the same truck, I was in my 83 K10. He was trying to climb out of a steep snowy icy hill about 30 ft tall at my uncles property. On his 3rd attempt he was almost at the top, I was spotting again. He was full throttle, throwing snow, ice and some dirt all over the place. And then crunch, followed by hellacious noises in the Dana 44 with the tires doing funny motions. I pulled him out of there with my truck, and we unlocked the hubs and drove it home to investigate. The spider gears were in I swear at least 40 pieces. So what does he do, he washed them all off and welds them back in piece by piece in the axle housing! Only this time, he welds them as one solid chunk he called the Hobart locker since he wasn't using a Lincoln. It worked, for a long time like that.

So I guess my sarcastic story is 0, or maybe 1 trans so far? What do you call it when its broke but you still drove it home down the freeway? 1/2 a break?
 
Last edited:
I call that "wounded", not broken.

My first car was a 65 Wildcat with the 401 nailhead, and switch Pitch TH400. I literally can't tell you how many times I neutral dropped that car at minimum 5000 rpm. It's been 35 years and I still think I deserve a beating for that. Never broke or even wounded the trans. Sure went through tires...
 
I know a guy back home when I was a kid that would do "J hooks" he called them in his 70s Firebird.

He would put it in reverse, and floor it, burn rubber in reverse, and right before it would hook, he would slam it into 1st gear without letting off the throttle. It would make these J shaped burnout marks. He went through several trans doing that, usually the converter would get shelled inside.
 
I had a 76 Suburban with a th350 and reverse would slip badly. The forward gears worked perfectly. I drove it like that for 3 years before I sold it. I always had to remember to park strategically, so I didn't have to back uphill out of any spots :rotfl:
 
I had a 76 Suburban with a th350 and reverse would slip badly. The forward gears worked perfectly. I drove it like that for 3 years before I sold it. I always had to remember to park strategically, so I didn't have to back uphill out of any spots :rotfl:

you reminded me of a car my buddy had way back in the day. My buddy had a 69 Pontiac 2+2. Canadian car, so Chevy powered with a 275 hp 350 and TH350. He wrecked it coming down from Mt Baker on a really tight turn, so it definitely wasn't pretty anymore. Shortly after reverse takes a permanent vacation. park brake cable is broken. This thing is 5 minutes from death...but being a broke ass kid my buddy kept driving it. Park strategically etc.

Fast forward a few months and he gets pulled over because the car is a huge heat score at this point. Cop tells him the car looks unsafe and he wants to perform a roadside safety. Horn works, all the lights work, tires are decent and the cop is getting a little frustrated he hasn't found anything wrong other than ugly. Next up he figures he'll get him on the parking brake. The cop tells my buddy to set the parking brake, so he does (it's focked and non-op) then the cop tells him to put it in reverse. So with a straight face my buddy puts the car in reverse. It doesn't move. The cop then tells him to give it some gas, and don't be a pussy about it. My buddy revs it to about 4000 rpm for about ten seconds, and the car doesn't move a millimeter. At this point the cop is disgusted, hand him back his license and papers and tells him "Son, this car is the biggest POS I've pulled over in months, but it has the best parking brake I've ever seen!" and let him go...
 
My favourite story was back in the day… me and my best friend got really drunk and our friends took out keys away from us… good idea!
But we got semi sober and pissed off. Got the keys back. Then proceeded to get even more drunk driving home.

“ Not a story we tell many people and obviously not The thing to do”

We where driving from Ladner to Abbotsford @tRustyK5 will know the route. We got half way back and lost all forward gears. We are driving my buddy’s 70 240z with a stock 4 speed BTW.

We where kind of screwed but we had reverse! Drove the rest of the way home in reverse! I don’t know how out of all the stupid shit that Has happened over the young years we didn’t die or get locked up! Thanks for the luck!

Have got a few trucks with bad trans that’s just needed fluid or a filter change.
 
My favourite story was back in the day… me and my best friend got really drunk and our friends took out keys away from us… good idea!
But we got semi sober and pissed off. Got the keys back. Then proceeded to get even more drunk driving home.

“ Not a story we tell many people and obviously not The thing to do”

We where driving from Ladner to Abbotsford @tRustyK5 will know the route. We got half way back and lost all forward gears. We are driving my buddy’s 70 240z with a stock 4 speed BTW.

We where kind of screwed but we had reverse! Drove the rest of the way home in reverse! I don’t know how out of all the stupid shit that Has happened over the young years we didn’t die or get locked up! Thanks for the luck!

Have got a few trucks with bad trans that’s just needed fluid or a filter change.
I don't know if I told this story already on CK5 or not but I did that twice in 2 weeks.
I had a 1978 Monte Carlo and I blew the transmission, no forward gears, only reverse.
I lived in the hills about 25 kilometers from the coast.
It was late evening so I drove in reverse the whole way average speed was 35 mph, whipping the front end on every hair pin curve.
The next day I put in a used transmission, drove it a couple of days and all seemed good so I went to visit a friend 70 kilometers away and wouldn't you know, as I was leaving his house I lost all forward gears.
I had to go on the highway for 30 miles, here I would have been pulled over and ticketed, but in Beirut I just got the funny looks and shaking heads.
Made it home in 2 hours.
My neck and back were hurting for 2 days.
 
Must have been before you were a truck driver, or you would have done that with your mirrors and saved your neck and back the agony. :waytogo:

We need this smilie, but after the first shift it should show parts exploding. :burnout:
 
Took a little road trip, from Wasilla to Wasilla via Tacoma, the Coast Road, LA, Fort Worth, Dayton, Ann Arbor, and Montana. Driving down the 101 For whatever reason my stupid self got the red mist and I came out to pass a winnebago, got up to about 90 and another winnebago came into my lane. I didn't have escape room on either side and I wasn't going to get ahead of the winnebago on my right, so I stood on the brakes and boiled 'em, grabbed the shifter and pulled second, got tucked in behind the guy I was originally trying to pass with maybe a foot of clearance.

That poor trans let go in a big way.. 15 thousand miles later, once I had towed a '72 Mercedes over the mountain at Bakersfield and through the desert and made it back home. Folks talk crap about the 4l60e, but it's always been good to me. Shame about the trans cooler being in the radiator though.
 
Must have been before you were a truck driver, or you would have done that with your mirrors and saved your neck and back the agony. :waytogo:

We need this smilie, but after the first shift it should show parts exploding. :burnout:
Do you trust going 35mph backwards on the highway without watching directly?
I still wouldn't.
 
I spend half my life in reverse, but in parking lots and stuff. On the highway I think there'd be less to worry me. I routinely reverse on the pin.

I will say in a car it's a lot harder as the steering geometry is much less forgiving, and it can be really easy to get the whole sway back and forth going. Not sure I'd care to do that for more than a mile or two. :doah:
 
I believe that I hit 24 mph in reverse on I-70 once in a heavy wrecker with a small sleeper, for a little over a mile. 310" wheelbase sure helped.
I wouldn't want to do it in a car, going faster and farther. Big mirrors sure help, too!
 
My 83- burnt the th350 at least 10 times before it started to lose gears.
Swapped to a th400, it started to get really noisy when i swapped to a nv3500.

83 k5- toasted the 700r4 on a snowy hill climb, went full neutral.

79 f100- bent the shift forks power shifting into 3rd racing a civic

91 suburban- trans pump started to fail, it was slipping bad when i sm465 swapped it.
16 mazda 3- attempted to race my wife in her mustang. It didn't like the hard shifting and went full neutral.

07 Mustang- bad rebuild by previous owner but let go with me driving.
 
Top Bottom