I have one of those Fel-Pro one piece gaskets right now on a new crate engine with about 15,000 miles on it, and have no problems with it leaking around the rear main seal. The pan and engine are new so the sealing surfaces may be better that an older engine with an older pan. Using a thin layer on the whole gasket, and making sure you have a good bead of RTV in the pan corners would be a good idea with an older engine with an older pan.