I guess its all preference and it depends on what you are doing. What was said above is correct. If your fourwheeling on rocks like a lot of us here, then 4" is generally better cause it offers more flex and a lower cog. If your mud bogging, then you might get swamped with 4" and maybe a 8-12" lift is better. It wont articulate, but it will keep you out of the mud.
-Harrison