I'm in here late but a long straightedge across the face of the pullies would have magnified any misalignments.
It’s pretty tough to get anything down in there across any of those surfaces.I'm in here late but a long straightedge across the face of the pullies would have magnified any misalignments.
I don't know if you have this figured out yet but I agree that most likely something is not at the right angle.If it's coming off with just the starter motor, something is really off. Your mount may have the compressor at an angle. If you can get an angle finder on the clutch and the crank, that verifies in that direction, then a straight edge should show if it parallel to the front of the block. https://www.gatesaustralia.com.au/~...anincreasebeltdrivewhitepaper-performance.pdf
I don't think you want the belt riding against a stationary object. If you make a guide, it should be part of the pulley, so it's turning. At least as proof of concept, you might be able to swap the smooth tensioner pulley for a ribbed one, since they have sides on them. But still, any misalignment of pulleys will make the belt wear out faster and the noise may be obnoxious.