Very common on many GM SBC exhaust manifolds,for only one side to need a donut gasket...just clean up the metal casting before installing the exhaust pipe and it will not leak..
One engine swap I did with a friend was 99% completed on a Sunday night,we thrashed all weekend to yank out the dead engine and install the good one,and the lone thing holding us up was we had no exhaust donuts ,and we needed one for one side...
I needed to drive the truck to work the next morning--so we searched his shop for anything else we might be able to use..
I found a old battery cable in his rubbish can,I cut off about 4" of it and twisted the ends together in a circle,and used a propane torch and some solder & paste flux to "fll" the copper wire strands till they were completely covered..made my own copper/lead donut..
I put it on and tightened the bolts good on the flange...figured it'd get me by for awhile,till I got a donut gasket..but it never gave me any grief,so I just left it in!..it worked better than a real donut gasket..
I have seen some metal donuts used on some manifolds..