I too,am confused when I view the gasket maker aisles in parts stores now...back when I sold the stuff,there was about 4 different ones--the "original" semi-transparent blue stuff,"Ultra-Blue" that supposedly worked the best under constant exposure to oil, the "Ultra-HI-Temp" orange stuff good for 650 degrees,and they just introduced "Ultra-Copper" when I was leaving the parts counters...
Now they have Ultra-Black,Grey,"The Right Stuff" and probably a half dozen others...
I will be needing some soom to seal up the oil pan to engine on my 6.2,and dont really know which one is "best" for that purpose..my friend reccomends the black stuff,but he doesn't use the "Right Stuff" because he doesn't like the presurized cans it comes in,he's got more than one that refused to release anything and the store wouldn't refund him his money...
I was rather shocked to see most of the toothpaste sized tubes of this stuff now sell for 8 to 12 bucks,it was 2.99 last time I used any!..

..yes,its been that long..what sucks is I have two tubes of "Ultra-Blue",still unopened in the blister packs from the 90's that are hard as granite,I guess it eventually hardens even in the tube if its never been opened..