Same cap/rotor on the truck that I bought (well used when I got it) ran it for about 5 years, cleaned twice, got 18MPG best, averaged 15MPG freeway, 10-13 city. Those mileage numbers were enough to sell me on used parts being perfectly adequate when in good shape.
Not bad considering everything that conspired to defeat economy on that truck. That was my main gauge of the engines performance, economy. If economy suffered, something was wrong, and that was always the case.
I'm not going to skimp on something like oil, I don't have the equipment to test the additives and how much its broken down, but something I can visibly inspect, I won't replace "just because".
Heck, the way things are now, replacing known good, but used, parts is riskier than leaving them in place with the aftermarkets track record.