I have a Warn 9500Ti. I noticed the other day when I was pulling a Samurai back on its tires that when I stopped spooling in the winch would let line spool back out until I pushed the switch again. Is this right? I can't remember it doing that before, but I don't winch too often and I usually am not doing anything technical where I have to spool, stop, spool, stop etc. Usually its just spool in and stop when the Jeep is unstuck 
How do I fix this?

How do I fix this?