CK5
Register an account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members.

Wix vs Fram

hunterguy86

1/2 ton status
Joined
Jan 10, 2005
Posts
2,477
Reaction score
1
Location
San Marcos, Texas
I always use Wix filters but my buddies say fram and wix are no diffrent.

I want to prove them wrong. Anybody got pics of them cut open or any other proof that wix is better? I know wix is better but i need documented facts to win this debate.
 
http://www.geocities.com/MotorCity/Speedway/1080/oilfiltertech.html

wix and hastings are the same, fram is not apart of them.

wix gold is better

frams low and high grade aren't as good as thier mid grade, "tough gaurd" .The X2 gimmic in the can is a joke.

the article says that frame has half the filter material in thier filters, but it didn't state what grade of each filter they tested.




The way i see it is this. buy the best that you can afford for it knowing that in 3 months (or 3,000 miles) you are changing it out anyways. I'v always ran the mid grade fram after first hearing this like 5 years ago. just the cop car get wix as that is what it has been on it's whole life.
 
X2 Wix around here is hard to find, so I use the Napa Gold. Never had a problem with them, and they don't seem to have the pressure fade I have seen with the Fram's.
 
hunterguy86 said:
but my buddies say fram and wix are no diffrent.

You can congratulate your buddies on being the sheep that makes advertising effective... :wink1:

I've been using Wix long before anyone knew who they were... quality filter... frams suck....

Here's a link I had kicking around thats pretty in-depth...

http://minimopar.knizefamily.net/oilfilters.html
 
So is my brother wasting his money by buying royal purple and using a bosch filter. I always thought Bosch and/or K&N were decent...? What about the Mobil1 filters?
 
The quickest way I know of proving it is just pick the two filters up and see which one weighs more. The Wix wins every time because it has more of the element in it.
Napa filters are Wix filters I think the part #s are even close.
 
kablooie said:
So is my brother wasting his money by buying royal purple and using a bosch filter. I always thought Bosch and/or K&N were decent...? What about the Mobil1 filters?

Ok, this is a different subject. You have two types of filter media.... cellulous and nanofiber medias.

Fram, Wix, Hastings, Baldwin, economy Fleetguard.... all cellulous filter media is used in these. The question on hand is the quality and amount of media used. Cellulous is good media but it looks like swiss cheese under a microscope. Nanofiber media has much more consistant hole sizes.

The difference between the two is that the larger holes in cellulous allows for more large particle movement before being trapped compared to the uniform holes in nanofiber media. Also, nanofiber media provides more actuall particle storage than cellulous. This is why sometimes nanofiber filters are suprisingly smaller in size. The last benifet is media stamina. It takes roughly twice as long for nanofiber media to start to break down and fall apart internally.

As for applications.....(and actually getting to your question...:crazy: ) a quality cellulous filter like a Wix or Baldwin goes great with conventional oil and economy synthetics. You can usually figure close to 10,000 miles out of a good cellulous filter in good conditions.

Nanofiber is usually teamed up with high quality synthetics designed for extra long extended drain intervals where a filter that can keep from falling apart, along with having the storage capacity, to keep up with the oil in a long 20K oil interval run.

Fleetguard stratopore, Amsoil, RP, and Donoldson Endurance (what I use) are the nanofiber lines that I am aware of.
 
roadnotca said:
And if you can't find Wix, use NAPA.

i work at napa in one of the warehouses, and ive learned wix makes napa's filters, also valvoline makes napa oil...now u know....i have to kill you:D
 

Latest Posts

Top Bottom