The p/n for the "3-bolt" style clamshell inserts is actually 3.1121.......not 3.1131 (probably just a typo, but..).
As mentioned, there are two styles of GM clamshell inserts. My '90 K5 with a factory 6.2 diesel and OEM mounts required the 3.1121 mounts which are also listed for newer trucks and for older ones with the 454. When I replaced mine they fit like they should......pretty tight but they went together and I used a vice to press the clamshells together and tiewrapped the two sides.
I had bought the 4 bolt style inserts (3.1116) first but it was quite obvious by just looking at the mounts that they were different. I can't remember off hand, but the two styles looked very similiar but they were different measurements. My guess is that the original poster simply bought the wrong version of the mounts.