I've had good luck with Edelbrocks,but its been since 2003 that I had one...gas has not gotten any better since then (or any cheaper!)--and I read about a lot of issues with them online now,with float and flooding when hot issues,etc..
Lots of posts I have read say they are sensitive to fuel pressure and do not like more than 3-4 lbs...Edelbrock says no,but there seems to be a lot of people who added a regulator and it cured their issues..others found the floats were way out of adjustment right out of the box,or metering rods would get stuck,etc,and needed tweaking to get them "right"..
...all the ones I ran always ran nice,started easy at any temperature,only issues I had was getting the choke set right--and carb icing on cool damp days and nights...(which happened with other carbs too,its more a humidity/weather related issue than a carb problem)....
If you were to replace it and plan on doing any off roading,I'd say a Q-jet is the best all around choice...