BUDDY
1/2 ton status
On my wife's Discovery:
Years ago, one of the lug studs on the driver's rear broke off whilst at the tire shop.
and we drove it like that with 4 lugs on it instead of 5, literally, for years. I have had the tires rotated and balanced many times since then, but I always took it in to do it because it was free with the tire purchase.
Finally, decide that it's time to replace the broken lug stud, so I get the other 4 lugs off, and I CAN NOT get the tire off!!
I have a 10 foot long cheater that is BENDING without any lug nuts on the wheel!!
I'm a pretty hefty fella these days and I've gotten tires off of anything else I've ever owned or stopped on the side of the road to help with, so I'm at a loss. But, I remember reading an article in 4wheeler probably 20 years ago where Granville King recommends as a last resort to leave one lugnut on hand tight & then drive a few feet with it on and it will break the wheel loose.
I am out of options at this point, so I say to myself, let's try it. Loosely put one lugnut back on, lower the jack, & drive slowly down the alleyway. (I adjusted the mirror down so that I could see the tire the whole time) I'll be damned if that frikkin' thing didn't even budge!! I drove around the block TWICE!! to get the wheel to START to wobble even a little bit.
By the time I was on the last quarter of the last lap, I was like, "screw it, this wheel is coming off!!" I am skidding and drifting around the corner, (as much as you can in a 5000lb AWD monster with traction control), and just as I get back to my driveway, I see it break loose in the mirror.
It stilll has the one lugnut on it & it isn't going anywhere, so I back into my workspace in the driveway again, jack it up AGAIN, pull that lug off AGAIN, use my 10 foot breaker bar AGAIN & the flippin' thing just barely pops off. WHEW!!
After that it was cake, but if I ever get a flat in that thing I'm just calling AAA straight off. I'd be screwed anyways, cause I don't normally carry around a 10 foot breaker bar.
Come to find out, that the OEM wheels on a Land Rover Discovery are not only "hub-centric", but that they are also, "lug-centric" as well. This little tid-bit means that once the center seat for the wheel lines up with the hub, that the lugs then have seats ALSO that line up with each lug. Basically, the wheel is "pressed-on" by the lugs which then, "press" themselves on when you torque them to the prescribed torque.
It was rediculous.
Later,
Buddy
Years ago, one of the lug studs on the driver's rear broke off whilst at the tire shop.
and we drove it like that with 4 lugs on it instead of 5, literally, for years. I have had the tires rotated and balanced many times since then, but I always took it in to do it because it was free with the tire purchase. Finally, decide that it's time to replace the broken lug stud, so I get the other 4 lugs off, and I CAN NOT get the tire off!!

I have a 10 foot long cheater that is BENDING without any lug nuts on the wheel!!

I'm a pretty hefty fella these days and I've gotten tires off of anything else I've ever owned or stopped on the side of the road to help with, so I'm at a loss. But, I remember reading an article in 4wheeler probably 20 years ago where Granville King recommends as a last resort to leave one lugnut on hand tight & then drive a few feet with it on and it will break the wheel loose.

I am out of options at this point, so I say to myself, let's try it. Loosely put one lugnut back on, lower the jack, & drive slowly down the alleyway. (I adjusted the mirror down so that I could see the tire the whole time) I'll be damned if that frikkin' thing didn't even budge!! I drove around the block TWICE!! to get the wheel to START to wobble even a little bit.
By the time I was on the last quarter of the last lap, I was like, "screw it, this wheel is coming off!!" I am skidding and drifting around the corner, (as much as you can in a 5000lb AWD monster with traction control), and just as I get back to my driveway, I see it break loose in the mirror.

It stilll has the one lugnut on it & it isn't going anywhere, so I back into my workspace in the driveway again, jack it up AGAIN, pull that lug off AGAIN, use my 10 foot breaker bar AGAIN & the flippin' thing just barely pops off. WHEW!!

After that it was cake, but if I ever get a flat in that thing I'm just calling AAA straight off. I'd be screwed anyways, cause I don't normally carry around a 10 foot breaker bar.
Come to find out, that the OEM wheels on a Land Rover Discovery are not only "hub-centric", but that they are also, "lug-centric" as well. This little tid-bit means that once the center seat for the wheel lines up with the hub, that the lugs then have seats ALSO that line up with each lug. Basically, the wheel is "pressed-on" by the lugs which then, "press" themselves on when you torque them to the prescribed torque.
It was rediculous.
Later,
Buddy


