I replaced my inner seals with the newer two piece styel seals. Unfortunately I have done this several times in ths past year because the axle housing itself was in such poor shape. In any event, the last time I replaced the seals I noticied that the tube was not that dirty, there really isn't that much space in there. My concern is that if I put seals on the end, I can't tell if I lose an inner seal again. Let me know how it works out for you, I may be a beleiver yet.