I think some chrome could be strategically placed on that blacked out truck and look just as good with or without chrome.
I think either truck would look better with the wheels from the blacked out truck.
I think the second truck would look better with a different set of wheels because for me those wheels and the body side molding clash.
If I'm going to keep the nostalgic look of the body side molding I'd probably like either a factory rally wheel or something aftermarket that makes you say "did those wheels come factory on that truck?"
It really depends on your taste and preference.
Do you want a totally custom look or do you want something more like "mostly original with some mild accents" that keep some nostalgia?
Either way can look awesome as long as all of the accents go together.