As good as modern headlights are, particularly LED, I'd go with something modern for certain.
If you've driven a new vehicle with good headlights (you can tell by the cutoff) you know that the modern designs absolutely outperform the old stuff.
I've tested and tested while driving, high beams on my modern vehicle are nearly worthless for actually helping me drive. In my experience they increase the area that is lit, but do zero to increase the range, because the low beams do such an outstanding job.
I think as I've gotten older, my sight at night is worse of course, but technology has improved, and the old style lights are much more difficult to drive with.
Were I doing a one and done, I can see spending the money on a set of great lights.