Wish I never did, but they are only aftermarket fenders anyways.
It's all in what you want.
If you have a decent set of GM fenders it's an investment to replace them.
Make a nice single cut if u do and u can always weld or braze the pieces back on .
Also u can weld the lip back on the trimmed section for the original look.
I went back quite a bit at the lower edge to fit 38's years ago and had to weld up a piece to cover up a hole that was left from cutting into the secondary structure to the outer section of the fender.
Imho for a driver go with what tire will fit
37's are a tad big for that lift I would say.
Depends on your back spacing also as to where the tire sits in the ww also
All in what u want, nothing is irreversible, just time and cash.