IMO you have to look at both off the line and cruise/WOT. Either way, if the secondaries are TOO loose, or over rich, or the hangar operates too fast, you may end up with a stumble as they open...you open them too far or dump too much gas through the secondaries you *can* starve the carb of fuel. I've done it, but with a 415CID motor...leaning out the secondary rods JUST a touch allowed the fuel pump to keep up. (these were constant WOT blasts from idle)
I'm really not sure whats required to OPEN the secondaries air flow wise...as tight as I've seen some stock Q-jets, I imagine if you REALLY wrap the motor out, it would still open up. But that really requires some serious velocity...
I don't like the idea of slow closing secondaries...when I let off, I want them to close. You'll end up dumping extra fuel on decel. Again, I check to make sure that in ALL cases they close fully, no matter what position the air valve is in when I let go, or slowly allow them to close.
I read it in the Roe book, and I tend to agree, that the stock snorkel forces the incoming air to flow over the secondaries correctly, so thats something to contemplate. I kinda doubt cowl induction Q-jet cars were setup that way, but I've never looked at one.