ryokens $.02....
I'll bring up this point, from a guy who did 2 BB oil changes today..
one thing to keep in mind, is tools that crush filters, the above claw, and the various plier ones, commit's you on a path...
tho I do use a variety of pliers, ex large to small, for everything from big Mann dizzles to tiny filters on an Onan gen set... and I do have 2 sizes of the jaw ones, by far, what i use most often are a quality band one, and I must do 300 merc oil filters a year.. I have about 5 of em in various sizes, but 2 for the standard chevy filters...
there can be a BIG advantage to the band ones.... it is MUCH more difficult to deform the filter, whereas the others automatically start crushing it... and yes, of course I've seen filters you rip off to the base and get it spinning with chisel/hammer, C4, etc.... but those are time intensive/money losing jobs...
just trying to say that keeping the filter pretty intact can be a big advantage doing filters.....