I agree and disagree with you on some of your points. I agree that some people really don't need any sort of doubler. It really depends on the use of your rig. I ran a SYE241 for years (even with 44" boggers for 2 years, at a 39:1 crawl ratio). It worked fine, but was not ideal. It didn't stop me from wheeling as I did a lot with it. However, now going from a single case to a Titan/205 in my truck, I believe it made a world of difference. In more of a "trail-rig" that see's many different types of terrain, you find yourself wanting different gear ratios a lot depending on what you are hitting. In the real technical rock crawling stuff, double low is so fantastic it's not even funny. However, when I then go snow wheeling, 2:1 or 2.72:1 are far better. And yes, I can tell a difference between the two gear selections. You can "think" it's too close to tell all you want, but until you experience it, you won't know.
Those full tube buggies, especially rock bouncers build their rig around one crawl ratio on purpose, because they want to keep a certain tire speed in the meat of the power curve of their motor. And simply the way they are built is very, very different then a trail rig. Therefore, the way you drive them is very different too. And therefore, your desire's for certain gear ratios will be different. It's like trying to compare rolling an orange down a hill, and then rolling a bowling ball down a hill and expecting they will react the same...it's just not the same.
I had the same feelings as you before I ever went to a "doubler" type system. I thought it wasn't really needed and it was kinda a waste of money cause look at all the wheeling I could do and obstacles I could get over with just a SYE241. But now that I have done it, I will say it truly changed the whole characteristics of how the truck performs and how I'm able to drive lines. Before, in certain situations I would have to hit something harder to make the obstacle, that now I'm able to crawl because I have much more control. You can call BS all you want on that statement, but like I said, until you experience it, you will never know.