Ok, here is my take on it. All in all, it's an "okay" site, but it could be a LOT better!
> You are using a fixed width design. This does not allow users to take advantage of wide screen monitors. As a result, your site only fills about 75% of my screen and has a lot of empty white space on each side. Change this to a dynamic width layout.
> Animated GIFs have to go. They are distracting and old fashioned, basically telling users you are from the 80's.
> Mystery navigation has to go or be fixed. When I click on the About Us link and go to that page, now the link does not appear. The other links on the left side are now changed in position. In addition, there is a dramatic layout shift and everything moves up. You should have a standardized menu and layout. When you are on the racing page, the navigation jumps WAY down to the middle of the page. It should never move.
When I click some of the links, like the Hole in the Rock trip 2010, all of the sudden the navigation is completely gone from the left and is now up top. This is a very bad design.
Finally, your site references lots of other site links, but many are not in the nav bar. You should use a dynamic Nav bar that can keep up with all the links so they can be found from the navigation bar and not just the articles.
> Online catalog. Okay, that just has to go. It's clearly hand made and is hard to use. I can only imagine it is hard to update as well?
Buying anything takes you off site to some store provider, which is not very seamless to users.
I would recommend you look into some store software like OSCommerce (free) or CRELoaded (costs) and very powerful. Using that software will allow you to create categories and then slowly drill down to specific items, allow searches, show most popular products, apply discounts and coupons, etc.
In addition, you can handle payments on your site or via PayPal. PayPal lets you print shipping labels which is very nice.
> Product pages. Uh, they are very complex. You need to have a better system than listing everything on one page. Look at this page, for example:
http://www.offroaddesign.com/catalog/Dana60crossover.htm
You have options for a lot of trucks. That's okay, but you have to make it easy for people. Have links for the Make, then drill down to the year, the lift, and then whatever else. It should go like this:
Select your Make to view available products:
Chevy
Ford
Dodge
------------
Select your year:
1969-1973
1974-1987
1988-1991
------------
Select your lift:
None
2"
4"
6"
8"
------------
The products available for your truck are:
[list them]
------------
You MUST list every version of every product. If someone has to call you to get the "right" part for their truck, you have failed. It's like ordering a t-shirt - let me pick the color, the size, and the sleeve length online. All options MUST be available on the site.
Yeah, so that is some work for YOU, but it makes it easy for your customers who want to spend money - and easily. If you make it so they have to read through a list of 50 different versions they might feel intimidated or confused and be forced to call you.
Remember, the goal is to make it easy for people to find things and buy them. If your site is hard to use, people will call you, which makes the site unproductive and not doing a good job.
> What is the goal of your site? Are you a vendor who sells stuff? Are you trying to make money? If so, then your home page should be a new/hot/on sale SHOWCASE. Sure, you can have articles, but they should not come first. Products are what most people want, and if you focus on getting the product in front of the customer everyone is happy.
> Logo. Clicking your site logo should take you to the home page. Right now it does nothing. This is a web design standard. Go fix that!
> Omit needless words. Your homepage has several paragraphs on what you do and so forth, but that should NOT be there - it should be on the About Us page! No one reads most of that either, so keep it as short and simple as possible. Make the home page about products. Have a brief description of each one, and add a Buy Now button RIGHT THERE! Fewer clicks = more sales.
> Recommended products. Is someone buying a lift kit? How about you recommend they get a shackle flip kit or something else? If you have store software, you can often do this automatically and easily.
> Is it in stock? While you have products listed, it is always good to have the site keep track of inventory and be able to tell people if it's in stock (and will ship today) or will be a wait of xx days/weeks.
> Layout/graphics. The site is in desperate need of an update. Either find a new template and apply it or hire someone to make something for you. If you are smart, you will use a dynamic layout that has a header file (top, navigation), the body content, then the footer file (bottom part). That way the layout stays the same on all pages and you only have to update the middle content (you may already be doing this, of course!)
> Your site is green, but your links are blue. Come on, make the links either black (best) or green so they fit in. You can apply that change in your stylesheet in seconds! Ok, you don't have a stylesheet, go get one. You can apply changes to every page all at once, it's really simple!
> Product categories. You really need to make some high level categories and then drill down. You have two steering categories. That is silly. What you should have is sections for each Year/Make truck, such as 69-73, 74-87, and 88-91 etc. Then in there have "Steering" and then from there drill down to Steering boxes, Linkage, Knuckles, etc, for EACH series of truck. You may have to cross list on product many times, but at least people can easily say "Oh, hey, this will work with my truck."
> Be sure you do not list any products which are not available. If it is sold out, REMOVE it from the listing. If it is special order, make it very clear that it's not in stock.
> Nothing should say "Call us" for details, pricing, etc. You are only open 9-5, and I get off work at 5:30. I can never call you so I will Google search somewhere else that I can ask questions.
> Get a support forum. VBulletin is a great forum product, and if you add it and call it a customer support forum people can ask questions there. You can answer them at your leisure and then the answers are there for other folks. Make a link to each category in the forum from each product and category in your store (I.e., Store - Steering - link to "Steering" forum) so people can go look or ask questions easily.
> Hot products. What are your best sellers? List them on the home page and let people know they are hot! Explain why.
> Reviews. If you are using store software, people can post reviews. Based on that you may find out about problems with your products, documentation (or lack of!), customer service issues, etc. Let people provide feedback, both good and bad, so you can learn from it and improve the store, products, and site.
> Navigation again - once you are in the store, there is no breadcrumb navigation which I can click to see other products in the same category. I'm looking at softtops, for example, and there are links to steering parts. Why? Show me ONLY exterior parts. You even link to soft tops on the soft tops page! Tsk, tsk!
> Errors. One page has a link to "Coming soon". When I click that, it goes nowhere and I get an error page. (
http://www.offroaddesign.com/catalog/steeringkit.htm). Fix that. You should have NO "Under construction" or "Coming soon" pages. Either the page works or it does not exist.
> Contact us. Your "disclaimer" of "
A note about email - we're a small growing shop and try as we might, we don't always answer emails in a timely manner. If you have a time sensitive question, you will be better off calling for information." is horrible! While your intentions are nice, you are saying "We're slackers!" You should simply say "Please allow 2 business days for replies, or post questions in our support forums [link]." And if you give out your email address, you MUST REPLY TO EVERYONE!
> When people do contact you and ask a question about a product, you should UPDATE the product. If one person asked, then 9 other people have the same question. Save yourself headaches and improve your search engine rankings at the same time by putting more content with each product.
Think about this - when you guy something from Amazon.com or Best Buy how do their sites work? They allow people to quickly and easily find products by searching and drilling down. You should too.
I hope that helps. Don't cry too much, I do web design for a living, so I just call it like I see it! 