If the injectors and cp3 have been done recently, had its normal fluid changes and what not I don't know how afraid of it I would be, my worries would be in the rest of the truck falling apart.
I'd rather tow with a 350k lb7 than a 80-150k 6.0
I don't understand the love of the 6.0/8.1 for towing. Shitty gas mileage and 55 mph don't do it for me.
I'll take my tuned and deleted lmm over any other diesel/gas any day of the week.
As a lb7 dmax motor owner, I can tell you to check the balance rates to see if the injectors are good or bad. As close to zero is the best number. Anything over/under +-4 is bad. Check when the truck is warmed up. 1900ish for a set if bad. It isn't a bad job, just time conduming . Everything on the Allison is expensive. So if it hasn't been gone through recently I'd start saving to a rebuild.
That being said I love my truck and would pick it to tow anything over my dads 01 2500hd with the 8.1/ally.
The off idle torque is the only thing the 8.1 has on my truck.
Not everyone needs a diesel to tow, especially if you are a "tow once or twice a month" type of guy (like some of us). In that case, I don't think you need to deal with the higher cost to purchase and the higher cost to own just to justify going 10 more mph up a pass and getting 5 more mpg's. If you tow a couple times a week or need it for work, well sure then it's a no brainer to go diesel, but I think it's dumb for the weekend warrior type of guy.
And saying the 6.0/8.1 gets crappy gas mileage towing compared to an LB7 is an incorrect statement as most I have seen will at most get 15 mpg's when towing (at most) with an LB7. Sure the 8.1 get 10 mpg's towing or empty, but guess what, when you need to replace the injectors in that it costs ~$200 and a couple hours of your time. Can you say the same for your diesel? Now, if you want to DD an 8.1, that's kinda stupid as then you are throwing money in the toilet for no reason with the mileage, that's why I said a 6.0 would be a good choice if you plan to drive it during the week to and from whatever you are doing.
Either way, there are pluses and minuses to every single truck depending on what you plan to use it for. You will most likely have to make a sacrifice somewhere, just depends on what sacrifice you are willing to give up with your truck. Hopefully some comments in this thread have given the OP some ideas on his own direction.
This is a pretty interesting thread to read through about buying a used diesel (look past all the typical pirate4x4 childish bantering back and forth). There are some actual good points for both gas and diesel that are worth noting:
http://www.pirate4x4.com/forum/tow-rigs-trailers/2320529-15k-tow-rig-what-would-you-buy.html

