is just do a nice trim job on those fenders and leave it be. no point in spending good money to fix something if your gona continue to wheel it and cut it up again. keep those fenders on, that way if more damage happens to them, no big deal. then eventually once you decide to tone back your wheeling habbit, swap in new fenders and pretend like nothing ever happened 
i know if i went through the trouble of fixing minor damage like with new fenders and then did it again a couple months later i would be pissed at myself that i spent all that money. my truck was really clean too before i started wheelin it. its still very clean, with just minor damage. eventually im going to cherry it out after i decide to either a) stop wheeling it, or b) can afford to buy a beat up rig that will be trail only.

i know if i went through the trouble of fixing minor damage like with new fenders and then did it again a couple months later i would be pissed at myself that i spent all that money. my truck was really clean too before i started wheelin it. its still very clean, with just minor damage. eventually im going to cherry it out after i decide to either a) stop wheeling it, or b) can afford to buy a beat up rig that will be trail only.
btw, trim away!

Go ahead join us become "THAT GUY" I know ya want to


) then, I did the little smoothing out and painting of the cut areas. I think they came out quite well, here's a pic: