It's not the ten bolt that is the problem, it is the gov-lok this time that cracked. It was a used unit that went in there last time when I got this axle. So the gov-lok is the weak point this time around.
My only concern with the 14 bolt is the re-welding the spring perches an shock mounts! I have no shop around here that I know of that I can trust to get the welding done correctly an accurately. I have a local welder but he is not a gear head welder, just a repair what you broke welder, or weld what you give him setup welder. He could know how to do it but I'm not sure!
I also don't want 8 lug rims. I like my custom billet rims an don't want to invest in a new set of rims an tires.
Now the 6 lug semi-float 14 bolt seem okay but again the welding custom work needed is a bit of a problem at this point. If it was a straight bolt up I would be all over it. A 12 bolt axle would be nice but they are harder to find.
I just need the rig back on the road in the fastest an cheapest way possible. I had always thought about upgrading the axles but I drive almost all pavement with towing occasionally right now so bigger axles isn't high on the to do list. Once I put the new 33" tires on I will be looking a little more into beefing up the axles since I just put my 3" suspension lift on the truck. I don't wish to go larger than 33" tires so a 10 bolt shouldn't have a problem holding up! This time the gov-lok seemed to be the week link which it is always known to be the weakest point in the 10 bolts since day one.
The issue with 10 bolt axles IS with the carrier be it a gov-lock or an open carrier, they just aren't up to the task once the tire size has been changed to any larger size.