Well, that was unexpected. I would have never looked at these 2 fans and picked the brushed fan as the better option.
I didn't even want to swap them in I was so convinced that it wasn't the problem, but I wanted to swap the water pump even less so I did the fans first. 100°+ outside, sameish drive, then parked it at my friends house and let it sit with the A/C blasting, the fans would actually cool it down to 205° and shut off. I wasted so much time trying to figure something out.
They are still pretty borderline at keeping it cool. I'm going to talk to Ron Davis and see if he can recommend a better fan for it. I'll also be talking to DeltaPAG about returning the fans, but that's probably not going to work out.