Where I'm kind of confused is on ride quality vs. body roll and axle wrap. Everyone complains about the body roll with 52's and some speak of axle wrap. Other than durability, how does the custom pack avoid the pitfalls of the 52's while still riding nice?
Here's where I'm coming from - The back of my K5 is nice and soft going over bumps with stock 52's, while the front is much harsher on the same bumps with EZ-rides. It's almost like it wants to jump up. I would try to blame the cheap shocks, but I have the same shock in all 4 positions - it can't just be high compression damping. So I'm convinced that a spring about as soft as 52's is needed for good ride quality, but with EZ-rides and no sway bar I already have an appreciable amount of body roll.
How is this dilemna solved? Are the Bilsteins the key to controlling body roll - increased damping at low piston speeds?
Having the same shock at all 4 corners isn't helping. In the tune-able shock world you run very different setups front and rear. So what your feeling can be a shock issue.
Keep in mind that I can take the race car and make it ride like a dump truck, or a Cadillac just with shock valving. There is more to shocks that you can imagine but at the same time the average Joe is going to be pretty happy with a Rancho 9000 type shock that has some adjustment in it.
You are beginning to understand the reason spring rate, shocks and anti sway bars all go hand in hand. For the average Joe a lift spring, dump the sway bar and put on some Rancho 9000's and you have a way cool suspension.
Once you start tuning and trying to get good ride and handling at the same time you need to start working and testing.
In general you can:
Use stiff springs to counter body roll
This provides a harsh ride pretty much at all times but there is limited body roll. Shocks will play a roll in ride but on a limited basis.
Use stiff shock valving to slow down the rate with which the body will roll while using a reduced rate spring pack.
Meaning you can't stop body roll with shocks, all you can do is make the valving stiff enough to where the fluid moving through the piston provides enough resistance to make the body roll happen slower. The body will ultimately roll the same amount but it can take many seconds for this to happen. HOWEVER, the ride quality will suffer and be very much like the above over sprung vehicle or worse.
Run a correct spring rate, Well valved and tuned shocks no anti sway bar.
You will have suitable ride for your preferences. Now the big question is, is the body roll acceptable to YOU. I will use Wade/KTMoutfront as my example. You can see videos of his blazer having what I deem as excessive body roll, however having talked with guys that have ridden with him they feel it wasn't terrible bad and in conversations with Wade he isn't in a hell fire hurry to install anti-swaybars. He knows they will help but since it hasn't happened he obviously feels it's okay.
Run the same setup as above but add in a correctly setup anti-swaybar.
Now all the anti swaybar does is provides added spring rate by twisting the bar. Body roll is resisted by the added spring rate only, this spring rate only effects things when there is a twisting force applied to the bar so it really is very un-noticeable. When correctly setup you will have very little to no loss in articulation, good ride quality both in corners and straight roads, and a anti-swaybar that is going to live a long and happy life.
It really comes down to what is acceptable to you? I know guys that don't like soft springs because of body roll, I also know guys that use the same spring pack and are totally happy with it and think the body roll is not bad and they can just deal with it.
Has anybody ridden on both ORD customs and 52" front springs?
Chris and Stephen at ORD are the only people I can think of off the top of my head that might have. This years UA truck and Chris' blazer?