Run it with 3.73's for now and see how you like it. You can always regear later.
Martin
That's one option but here is my dilemma.
I'm working with a very small budget, that will require me to sell off any left overs. I'm a pretty good trader so I'm trying to prove to my wife (call it a bet if you like) that I can do this whole upgrade for $200 dollars or less. I can trade as much as I want and even exceed the cash budget but when the double diff swap (that started off as a simple 3.08 to 4.56 regear) is done the total spent has to be $200 or less.
So here is the score:
I purchased a 14bff 4.56 for $200
Two days later I came across the sweet deal on the two axles that sparked this whole thread. Originally I bought them to flip which would easily leave me having made a profit on the upgrade.
However this particular Ford D60 happens to be just about every off-roaders wet dream, it fits in my rig, and I know I'll probably never have the chance to buy another one.
So I have a tough decision to make. Here are my options.
I can...
A: Sell the D60 and the matching 14b, get a set of 3/4 ton spindles to convert my 10 bolt, since I already have an 8.5" 4.56 R&P and a flat top D44(p) knuckle, make a nice profit, and hope like hell the front holds up.
B: Sell the D60 and the matching 14b, buy a 3/4 ton D44 and regear it. Come in on budget.
C: Keep the D60, and my 4.56-14b, sell the 3.73-14b and my 3.08-10b, trade my NP208 for an NP241, barely make budget and leave out the front driveshaft, wait until I can regear it.
D: Keep both 3.73's, trade transfer cases, sell the rest and be done with it. (There would likely be no regear them both later option)
I'm pretty much torn between C & D, because I really want to keep it.
I guess I need to just bolt them both up and drive it while my old front is still in it and see which one I like better.
Or I could "choose the 3.73's" and have a "hard time selling the 4.56's" and sell my old front and every random left over part I can't use or don't want until I can afford the front regear "3.73's are easier to sell". In case you can't tell I'm married, and my wife couldn't possibly care less for my truck.
For tires I'm going to try to trade my 37's on 15" 6 lug wheels for a set of H1 take offs (we'll see). And no, I'm not forgetting U-bolts, U-joints, steering box, tie rods, etc. Donations welcome

If only I had bought that pair of 3/4 ton GM 4.10's when I first started looking and been done with it, but no, I had to hold out for 4.56 gears, and now I'm considering 3.73's