If somebody can convince me that I can install the header bar in the windshield and the snaps on the tailgate in a manner that rust will not set in, I am really, really leaning toward the tan soft top
Once you drill pretty hard not to induce rust, especially on the inside.
I still haven't convinced myself to drill the header for the snap strip which consists of 5 holes.
The tailgate is a magnet strip in the top so no drilling.
The bedside channels for the soft top get bolted on so you will have to come up with a nut system anyways.
And will still be bolted on the paint.
I know what you mean about scratching the paint when putting the hard top on and off. Even using towels on the paint when lowering the top. Really hard by your self.
My hard top has been hanging in the garage for several years. When the weather is bad no drive. Been caught in the rain but no biggie.
Here in the mid south we get enough nice days in the winter to drive and in the summer I do most of my driving in the evening.
Not a daily driver either.
Still looking to come up with a front section from a hard top a make a Bolt on header for a bikini or full soft top but thats a maybe.
Best thing might be to find a junkyard blazer you could cut the top of the bed sides off for the captive nut set up. Would be labor intensive tho.
There are structural bonding agents out there used to bond body panels together that might work to attach the captive setup as not to need to repaint due to welding. I'm sure ryoken knows about them.
The nuts are just rectangular plates with tapped holes held on with cage type metal covers that allow the nuts to float which I'm sure you know. Could be made with a little work.
Forums 2nd idea would using work but gets away from the original.
The original question about using the hardtop. Well if you wanted a roof you could have gotten one of those later models.
If I have the need I would just put the hard top on but my 74 is not restored like yours and with fresh paint.
Sorry for the ramble.