Welcome to the world of glitches... 
Since it is when going closed loop that would make me check wireing to O2 sensor all the way to PCM. If it all looks good check continuity with ohm meter and wiggle wire looking for a break. Then replace O2 sensor! Sooted O2 from rich makes tuning impossible, contamination from other chemicals can not be seen.

Since it is when going closed loop that would make me check wireing to O2 sensor all the way to PCM. If it all looks good check continuity with ohm meter and wiggle wire looking for a break. Then replace O2 sensor! Sooted O2 from rich makes tuning impossible, contamination from other chemicals can not be seen.





